Teknik Telekomunikasi    
   
Daftar Isi
(Sebelumnya) Comparison of office suitesComparison of TeX editors (Berikutnya)

Perbandingan -- spreadsheet software

Contents

Online versus Desktop

Web-based spreadsheets do not in general depend on a particular operating system or similar constraints and are therefore generally more portable by their nature than desktop applications.

Collaborative spreadsheets

Generally, online spreadsheets offer spreadsheet sharing and public sharing as part of their features which enables collaboration between multiple users.

Remote data update

Some on-line spreadsheets provide remote data update allowing data values to be extracted from other users' spreadsheets even though they may be inactive at the time.

Gnumeric (listed below as a desktop spreadsheet) is also used as the "back-end" processor in at least one on-line spreadsheet application (Editgrid).

Online spreadsheets

The following tables only provide a comparison of desktop spreadsheet applications.

For a list and links to comparisons of online (web-based) spreadsheets, see Daftar/Tabel -- online spreadsheets.

Google spreadsheets

Google spreadsheets can be accessed from the documents window Google docs. To create a spreadsheet, the user must create an account.

Once with an account, the user can create a spreadsheet from scratch, or import data from an external spreadsheet or other sources. An example spreadsheet can be found here.

The spreadsheet has the capability of being read and worked on directly by using a web link. If the originating author elects that option, multiple authors can work on the same spreadsheet.

The capabilities of the spreadsheet have been perceived to be quite limited in comparison to, for example, Microsoft Excel. Google spreadsheet does not allow the use of named variables, and until recently had nothing comparable to Excel's programming feature (Visual Basic for Applications), but now Google Spreadsheets supports Javascript-based formulas that are quite powerful and expressive.

Desktop spreadsheets

General

ScreenshotCreatorDevelopment startedFirst public releaseLatest stable versionCost (USD)License
Calligra SheetsCalligra Sheets 2.4 screenshot.pngKOffice KSpread Team  2.6.1 [edit]  (20 February 2013; 22 days ago (2013-02-20)[1])FreeLGPL
GnumericGnumericGNOME community199819981.12.0 [edit]  (December 2012; 2 months ago (2012-12)[2])FreeGPL
IBM Lotus Symphony IBM 20081.3 / 2009FreeProprietary
LibreOffice CalcLibreOffice CalcThe Document Foundation20103.3 / 2011-01-254.0.1 [edit]  (6 March 2013; 8 days ago (2013-03-06))FreeLGPL
Mariner CalcMariner CalcMariner Software198819895.6.0$49.95Proprietary
Mesa P&L Software199019913.1 / 2006-08$34Proprietary
Microsoft ExcelMicrosoft ExcelMicrosoft1982198514.0.5128.5000 (32-bit) / January 2010$239 (Standalone price; also can be purchased in various Microsoft Office bundles with varying prices)Proprietary
NumbersNumbersApple, Inc. August 7, 20072.1 / July 20, 2011$79 (iWork '09 suite; also includes Pages and Keynote)

$20 on Mac App Store

Proprietary
OpenOffice CalcOpenOffice CalcOracle Corporation2000Build 638c / October 20013.4.0 / May 08, 2012FreeApache License v2
PlanMaker SoftMaker Software GmbH 1994[3][4]2010Free - SoftMaker Office 2008,
or € 69.95 - SoftMaker Office 2010
Proprietary
Quantrix Quantrix ?Early 1990s4.0 / 1Q 2011$1,549, or moreProprietary
Quattro Pro Corel19881988X6 ?Proprietary
Resolver OneResolver OneResolver Systems20052008-01-161.9 / 2010-06-04Free as part of an open source project or to create open source spreadsheet systems or $99open source / Proprietary
SiagSiag OfficeUlric Eriksson1996 3.6.1 / 2006FreeGPL
SSuite Accel Van Loo Software200220058.1FreeFreeware
Tables Daniel Schwill2004First Public Beta / 2005-121.5.3 / 2009-05-01$42Proprietary

Operating system support

The operating systems the software can run on natively (without emulation).

WindowsMac OS XLinuxBSDUnix
GnumericYesYesYesYesYes
IBM Lotus SymphonyYesYesYesNoNo
KSpreadbetabetaYesYesYes
LibreOfficeYesYesYesYesYes
Mariner CalcNoYesNoNoNo
MesaNoYesNoNoNo
Microsoft ExcelYesYesNoNoNo
NumbersNoYesNoNoNo
OpenOffice CalcYesYesYesYesYes
PlanMakerYesNoYesNoNo
SSuite AccelYesNoNoNoNo
Quattro ProYes    
Resolver OneYesNoNoNoNo
SiagNoYesYesYesYes
TablesNoYesNoNoNo
WindowsMac OS XLinuxBSDUnix

Import/export capabilities

This table gives a comparison of what file formats each spreadsheet can import and export. "Yes" means can both import and export.

OpenOffice.org XML
(sxc)
CSVExcel
(xls)
HTMLLaTeXODF
(ods)
OOXML
(xlsx)
PDFDIF
GnumericImportYesYesYesExportYesYesExportImport
IBM Lotus SymphonyYesYesYesExportNoYesImportExport 
KSpreadYesYesImportExportExportYesNoExport 
LibreOffice CalcYesYesYesYesNoYesYesExportYes
Mariner CalcNoYesYesNoNoNoNoExport 
MesaNoYesYesNoNoNoNoExport 
Microsoft ExcelNoYesYesPartialNoYesYesExportImport
NumbersNoYesYesNoNoImportImportExport 
OpenOffice CalcYesYesYesYesExport[5]YesYesExportYes
Quattro ProNoYesYesYesNoNoImportExport 
PlanMakerNoYesYesExportNoNoImportExport 
Resolver OneNoYesYesNoNoNoNoNo 
SiagImport partialYesImport partialYesExportNoNoExport 
TablesImport partialYesYesExportExportYesNoExport 
OpenOffice.org XMLCSVXLSHTMLLaTeXODF .odsOOXML .xlsxPDFDIF

Spreadsheet comparison tools

Looking for changes in spreadsheets or checking to see if two copies of a spreadsheet have identical content can be a mind-numbing exercise, especially for the larger and more complex spreadsheets. For Microsoft Excel, at least, the data file is amended each time the file is opened, even if there are no actual changes in the spreadsheet itself. For this reason; using file comparison will always show differences if the two files have different viewing (file opened) histories, even if the contents are identical. The following tools are helpful to find if there are any actual differences between different spreadsheet files.

CreatorDevelopment startedFirst public releaseLatest stable versionCost (USD)License
DiffEngineXDiffEngineX LLC199719972.28 / 2012-09-05$44 to $100 (30-day trial)Proprietary
Spreadsheet Compare 2004 ?1.16 / 2010-11-10FreeGPL
Compare Excel filesSpreadsheet Advantage ? ? ? / ?$299 (30-day trial)Proprietary
SynkronizerSynkronizer2000-07 ?9.5 / 2008-02€29 to €149Proprietary
Spreadsheet ProfessionalMiricle Solutions ? ? ? / ? ? (30-day trial)Proprietary

See also

References

(Sebelumnya) Comparison of office suitesComparison of TeX editors (Berikutnya)