Komputer & Telekomunikasi    
   
Daftar Isi
(Sebelumnya) Comparison of vector graphics ...Comparison of video encoders (Berikutnya)

Perbandingan -- video editing software

This is a comparison of non-linear video editing software applications. See also a more complete list of video editing software.

Contents

General information

This table gives basic general information about the different editors:

ProgramPlatformDeveloperYear of first releaseYear of latest releaseLatest versionLicense
Adobe Premiere ProWindows, MacAdobe Systems19912012
CS6 (6.0.3)[1] (September 27, 2012; 5 months ago (2012-09-27)) [±]Trialware
Adobe Premiere ElementsWindows, MacAdobe Systems2004201111 [2] (September 25, 2012; 5 months ago (2012-09-25)) [±]Trialware
Avid Free DVWindows, MacAvid ? ?1.8Discontinued (Commercial)
Autodesk SmokeMac, LinuxAutodesk ? ?2013Commercial
Xpress ProWindows, MacAvid2003 ?5.8Discontinued (Commercial)
Media ComposerWindows, MacAvid198920126.5.2 (December 19, 2012; 3 months ago (2012-12-19)) [±]Commercial
AvidemuxWindows, Mac, BSD, LinuxMean 20122.6.1GPL
AVS Video EditorWindowsOnline Media Technologies Ltd.200420136.3.2Commercial
Blender (VSE : Video Sequence Editor)Windows, Mac, Solaris, Irix, LinuxBlender Foundation200220132.66aGPL
CinelerraLinux, MacHeroine Virtual200220124.4GPL
Corel VideoStudioWindowsCorel Corporation1993 (Under Ulead)2013x6Trialware
PowerDirectorWindowsCyberlink2001201111 (October 19, 2012; 5 months ago (2012-10-19)) [±]Trialware
Montage ExtremeWindowsDayang200720091.2Commercial
EditDVWindows, MacRadius199720023.0Discontinued (Commercial)
EdiusWindowsGrass Valley Canopus20022013-02-216.53Commercial
Final Cut ExpressMacApple Inc.200320074.0.1Discontinued (Commercial)
Final Cut ProMacApple Inc.1999201310.0.8Commercial
FORsceneCross-Platform (Java)Forbidden Technologies2004 ?15 April 2007Commercial
iMovieMacApple Inc.199920109.0.8Commercial
KdenliveLinux, BSD, MacOpen Source Community200220120.9.2GPL
KinoLinux, BSDOpen Source Community200020091.3.4GPL
LightworksWindowsEditshare1989201211.0.3Freeware, Commercial
LiVESLinux, BSD, MacOpen Source Community200220121.6.2GPL
Magix Movie Edit ProWindowsMagixcirca 2001 (VideoDeluxe 1.0)201117 plusCommercial
MainActorLinux, WindowsMainConcept200420075.5Discontinued (Commercial)
MoviePlusWindowsSerif (Europe) Ltd20002011X5Commercial
MPEG Video Wizard DVDWindowsWomble Multimedia?20125.0.1.105Trialware
VideoPadWindows, MacNCH Software200820133.02Commercial
Nero Multimedia SuiteWindowsNero AG2002201111.0Commercial
OpenShot Video EditorLinuxOpen Source Community200820121.4.3GPL
Pinnacle StudioWindowsPinnacle Systems1999201216Commercial
Pinnacle VideospinWindowsAvid200920092.0Discontinued (Freeware)
PiTiViLinuxOpen Source Community200420120.15.2LGPL
Sony Vegas ProWindowsSony Creative Software1999201212Commercial
Sony Vegas Movie StudioWindowsSony Creative Software2000201111.0Commercial
Ulead MediaStudio ProWindowsUlead Systems (now Corel) ?20068.1Discontinued (Commercial)
VideoThangWindowsVideoThang LLC200720082.0.1Discontinued (Freeware)
VirtualDubWindowsAvery Lee200020121.10.2GPL
VirtualDubModWindows 200220061.5.10.2 b2542Discontinued (GPL)
Windows Movie MakerWindowsMicrosoft200020122012 (v16.4.3505.0912) (August 7, 2012; 7 months ago (2012-08-07)) [±]Freeware

System requirements

This table lists the operating systems that different editors can run on without emulation, as well as other system requirements. Note that minimum system requirements are listed; some features (like High Definition support) may be unavailable with these specifications.

WindowsMac OS XUnix-likeProcessorRAMHDD
Adobe Premiere Pro CS4 (32-bit)YesYes (as of CS3)No1.4 GHz, SSE2 compatible processor1 GB / 2 GB when editing HD4 GB
Adobe Premiere Pro CS5 (64-bit)YesYesNomulticore x64 compatible processor2 GB10 GB
Adobe Premiere Pro CS5.5 (64-bit)YesYesNomulticore x86-64 compatible processor2GB/ 4 GB when editing HD GB10 GB
Adobe Premiere Pro CS6 (64-bit)YesYesNomulticore x64 compatible processor8 GB10 GB
Adobe Premiere ElementsYesYes (as of v9)No2 GHz with SSE2 support2 GB4.5 GB
Avid Free DVYesYesNo933 MHz Pentium, 667 MHz PPC1 GB ?
Media ComposerYesYesNoIntel Core 2 Duo 2.33 GHz processor or faster4+ GB80 GB
Xpress ProYesYesNoPentium 4, PowerMac G51 GB20 GB
AvidemuxYesYesYes???
AVS Video EditorYesNoNoIntel / AMD compatible at 2500 MHz or higher1 GB1 GB
Blender (VSE : Video Sequence Editor)YesYesYes300 MHz128 MB20 MB free space
CinelerraNoYesYes500 MHz256 MB ?
Corel VideoStudioYesNoNoPentium 4 or higher, SSE2 when editing HD512 MB3 GB
PowerDirectorYesNoNoSSE2 compatible processor512 MB2 GB
Montage ExtremeYesNoNoPentium 4 or higher1 GB20 GB
EditDV ? ? ? ? ? ?
EdiusYesNoNoPentium 4 3.0 GHz+1 GB800 MB
Final Cut ExpressNoYesNo500 MHz384 MB1 GB
Final Cut StudioNoYesNo1.25 GHz G4, Intel Core Duo or Xeon1 GB4 GB Apps
FORsceneYesYesYesN/A256 MBAny
iMovieNoYesNoIntel based Macs1 GB5 GB
KdenliveNoYesYes600 MHz256 MB1 GB
KinoNoNoYes???
LightworksYesYes (planned)Yes (planned)Intel Core Duo, Intel Xeon or AMD processor2 GB200 MB
LiVESNoYesYes800 MHz128 MB10 GB
Magix Movie Edit Pro ? ? ? ? ? ?
MainActorYesNoYes700 MHz128 MB ?
MoviePlusYesNoNoPentium II or AMD Athlon XP128 MB149 MB
MPEG Video Wizard DVDYesNoNo233 MHz32 MB20 MB
VideoPadYesYesNomulticore x86 compatible processor1GBAny
Nero Multimedia SuiteYesNoNo2 GHz AMD or Intel processor512 MB (1 GB for Windows Vista or Windows 7) / 2 GB when editing HD5 GB
OpenShot Video EditorNoYesYes600 MHz256 MB1 GB
Pinnacle StudioYesNoNo1.8 GHz1 GB1.7 GB
Pinnacle VideoSpinYesNoNo1.4 GHz512 MB150 MB
PiTiViNoNoYes ? ?2 MB
Sony Vegas ProYesNoNo2.0 GHz1.0 GB400 MB
Ulead MediaStudio ProYesNoNo800 MHz256 MB800 MB
VirtualDubYesNoNo??3 Mb
VirtualDubMod ? ? ? ? ? ?
Windows Movie MakerYesNoNo1 GHz for best performance128 MB10 Mb
WindowsMac OS XUnixProcessorRAMHDD

"Unix" includes the similar Linux, BSD and Unix-like operating systems.

High definition import

The table below indicates the ability of each program to import various High Definition video formats for editing.

720p HDV1080i HDVDVCPRO HDUncompressed HDIMXAVCHDXDCAM HDHDVAVC-IntraDNxHDREDCODE
Adobe Premiere ProYesYesYesYesYes (3rd party)YesYesYesYesYes (third party via codec install)Yes
Adobe Premiere ElementsYesYesNoNoNoYes (As of 7.0) ?Yes ? ? ?
Avid Media ComposerYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
Avid Xpress ProYesYesYesNoNoYes ?Yes ?Yes ?
Avidemux???????????
AVS Video EditorYesYes ?YesNoYes ?Yes ? ? ?
BlenderYesYes ?YesNoYes ? ? ? ? ?
CinelerraYesYesYesYesYesNoYesYesYesYesNo
CyberLink PowerDirectorYesYes ?Yes ?Yes ?YesYes ? ?
Dayang Montage ExtremeYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNoYesNo
EDIUSYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes ? ?
Elecard AVC HD EditorYesYesNoNoNoYesNoYes ? ? ?
Final Cut ExpressYesYesNoNoNoYes ? ? ? ? ?
Final Cut StudioYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes (third party via codec install)Yes
FORsceneYesYesYesYesYes ? ? ? ? ? ?
iMovie HDYesYesYes (3rd party)NoNoYes ? ? ? ? ?
LightworksYesYesYesYesYes (as of Pro 11)Yes (as of Pro 11)Yes (as of Pro 11)YesYes (as of Pro 11)Yes (3rd party)Yes (as of Pro 11)
LiVESYesYes ?Yes ? ? ?Yes ? ? ?
PiTiViYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes ?
KdenliveYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNo
Kino GTK???????????
MainActor ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
VideoPadYesYes ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
MPEG Video Wizard DVDYesYes ? ? ?No ?Yes ? ? ?
Nero Vision Xtra/ Nero Video Premium HDYesYesNoYesNoYesNoYesYesNoNo
OpenShot Video EditorYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNo
Pinnacle StudioYesYesNoNoNoYes ?Yes ? ? ?
Serif MoviePlusYesYes??NoYes ?Yes ? ? ?
Sony VegasYesYesYes (3rd party)YesYesYesYesYes ? ?Yes (as of Pro 9)
Ulead MediaStudio ProYesYes ?YesNo ? ? ? ? ? ?
Ulead VideoStudio PlusYesYes ?YesNoYes ? ? ? ? ?
VirtualDubYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
WeVideoYesYesYes??YesYesYes???
Windows Live Movie MakerYesYesNo ? ?Yes ?Yes ? ? ?
Windows Movie MakerYesYesNoNoNoYes ?Yes ? ? ?
720p HDV1080i HDVDVCPRO HDUncompressedIMXAVCHDXDCAM HDHDVAVC-1DNxHDREDCODE

Feature set

High Definition supportNon-destructive editingFull-screen playbackStoryboard modeVideo tracksAudio tracks / max channelsLinear timecode displayGPGPU with OpenCL acceleration
Adobe Premiere ProYesYesYes, By hitting ctrl+~ (CS6 only)YesUnlimitedUnlimitedYesYes
Adobe Premiere ElementsYesYesYesYes9999Yes?
Avid Xpress Pro Media ComposerYesYesYesYes24 tracks, unlimited layers24 tracks, unlimited layersYes?
AvidemuxYesYes??12 / ???
AVS Video EditorYesYesYesYes11+Yes?
Blender (VSE : Video Sequence Editor)YesYesYesYesUnlimitedUnlimitedYes?
CinelerraYes
(any resolution)
YesYesNoUnlimitedUnlimited / 16Yes?
Corel VideoStudioYesYesYesYes64YesYes
CyberLink PowerDirectorYesYesYesYes100100YesYes
Dayang Montage ExtremeYesYesYesYes99 per sequence99 per sequenceYes?
EDIUSYesYesYes, on both PC & TV monitors in realtimeNounlimited realtime layersunlimited realtime layersYes?
Elecard AVC HD EditorYesYesNoNo ? ?Yes ?
Final Cut ExpressYesYesYes, with "external video"Yes, in the Media Browser99 per sequence99 / 2 per sequenceNo?
Final Cut StudioYesYesYes,Yes, in the Media Browser99 per sequence99 / 24 per sequenceYesYes
FORsceneInput onlyYesYes (podcasts)Beta test24Yes?
iMovie HDYesYesYesYes12Yes?
PiTiViYesYesYesNoUnlimitedUnlimited ??
KdenliveYesYesYesYesUnlimitedUnlimitedYes?
Kino GTK?YesYesYes????
LightworksYesYesYesYesUnlimitedUnlimitedYesPlanned
LiVESYes
(any resolution)
Yes
(multitrack mode)
Yes
(on first, second or all monitors, configurable)
NoUnlimitedaudio per video track + backing audio / 2 channelsYes?
MainActor ? ? ? ? ? ? ??
VideoPadYesYesYesYesUnlimitedUnlimited ?Planned
MPEG Video Wizard DVDYesYesYesYes13Yes?
Nero Vision Xtra/Nero Video Premium HDYesYesYesYesUnlimitedYesYesYes (CUDA)
OpenShot Video EditorYesYesNoNoUnlimitedUnlimitedYes?
Serif MoviePlusYesYesYes, & on separate monitor or TVYes, partialUnlimitedUnlimitedNo?
Sony Vegas ProYes

(any resolution)

YesYesNoUnlimitedUnlimited/Max Channel 16YesYes (as of 11)
Pinnacle StudioYesYesYesYesUnlimitedUnlimitedYes?
Ulead MediaStudio ProYesYesYes, on separate monitor ?99 ?Yes?
Ulead VideoStudio PlusYesYesYesYes79Yes?
VirtualDub?YesNoNo11Yes?
WeVideoYesYesYesNo1UnlimitedNo?
Windows Live Movie MakerYesYesYesYes ? ? ? ?
Windows Movie MakerYesNoYesYes12Yes?
HDNon-destructiveFull-screenStoryboardVideo tracksAudio tracksTimecode displayGPGPU with OpenCL acceleration

Output options

Please note that recording to Blu-ray does not imply 1080@50p/60p . Most only support up to 1080i 25/30 frames per second recording. Also not all formats can be output.

DVDHigh DefinitionSmart phoneJava phoneQuickTimeWindows MediaMPEG-4XML/EDLPrint to tapeWeb, not hostedWeb, hostedPodcasting
Adobe Premiere ProYesYes (Blu-ray)YesNoYesYesYesYesYesYesYes ?
Adobe Premiere ElementsYesYes (Blu-ray)YesNoYesYesYesNoYesYesYesYes
Avid Xpress ProYesYes (Blu-ray)NoNoYesYesYesYesYesYesNo ?
Avidemux???????Yes????
AVS Video EditorYesYes(Blu-ray)YesNoYesYesYesNoNoYesYesNo
Blender (VSE : Video Sequence Editor)YesYes??Yes?YesYes[3]????
CinelerraYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNoYesNoYes
CyberLink PowerDirectorYesYesYesNoYesYesYesNoYesYesNoYes
Dayang Montage ExtremeYesYesNoNoYesYesYesYesYes??No
EDIUSYesYes ?NoYesYesYesYesYesYesNo ?
Elecard AVC HD EditorNoYesNoNoNoNoYes (Part 10)NoNoNoNoNo
Final Cut ExpressYesYesYesNoYesYes (3rd party)YesNo (as of 2.5)YesYes ?Yes
Final Cut StudioYesYesYesNoYesYes (3rd party)YesYesYesYes ?Yes
FORsceneNoNoYesYesYes (MPEG 2)Yes (MPEG 2)?YesNoYesYesYes
iMovie HDYesNoYesNoYesYes (3rd party)YesNoYesYesYes (with .Mac)Yes
PiTiViYesYes ? ?YesYesYes ? ?NoNo ?
KdenliveYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes ?
Kino GTKNoNoNoNoNoNoYesNoNoNoNoNo
Lightworks ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
LiVESYesYes (AVCHD, Blu-ray)YesYesYesYesYesNoNoYesNo ?
VideoPadYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNoNoYesYesNo
MPEG Video Wizard DVDYesYes ? ?YesNoYesNoNoNoNoYes
Nero Vision Xtra/Nero Video Premium HDYesYes (AVCHD, Blu-ray)YesYesNoYesYesNoYesYesYesNo
OpenShot Video EditorYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNoYesYesYesYes
Serif MoviePlusYesYesNoNoYesYesYes?YesYesYes ?
Sony VegasYesYes (Blu-ray)NoNoYesYesYesYesYesYesNo ?
Pinnacle StudioYesYesYesNoYesYesYesNoYesYesYesYes
Ulead MediaStudio ProYesNoNoNoYesYesYesNoYesYesNo ?
Ulead VideoStudio PlusYesYesYes (via plug-in)Yes (via plug-in)YesYesYesNoYesYesYes (with DropShot) ?
VirtualDubNoNoNoNoNoNoYesNoNoNoNoNo
WeVideoNoYesYesNoNoNoYesNoNoNoYesNo
Windows Live Movie MakerYesYesYesNoNoYesNoNo?Yes??
Windows Movie MakerYesYesYesNoNoYesNoNoYesYes (WMV only)NoNo
DVDHigh DefinitionSmart phoneJava phoneQuickTimeWindows MediaMPEG-4XML/EDLPrint to tapeWeb, not hostedWeb, hostedPodcasting

See also

References

(Sebelumnya) Comparison of vector graphics ...Comparison of video encoders (Berikutnya)